Opinion 
 Blogs 
 National Comment 
 Lose the cancer shtick - it's not funny 

Lose the cancer shtick - it's not funny

Some things just aren't funny and we should be prepared to respect that.

IN THE movie Crazy, Stupid Love, which is being rented on DVD all over Australia after completing a successful cinema run, the newly estranged husband played by Steve Carell is overheard crying in the office toilet about his marital break-up. As word spreads, a work colleague raises the incident with Carell's character and learns he is going through a divorce. ''We all thought it was cancer,'' says the workmate, laughing heartily before announcing to a cheering office: ''It could've been cancer, buddy! Hey everyone, it's just a divorce.''

Some viewers might find the scene amusing. But try watching it with a cancer sufferer, as I did, and I guarantee you won't laugh a bit. Now, two weeks after my dear friend's passing, I'm just plain angry about it - the wretched scene is in one of the trailers promoting the movie. Just how insensitive to the suffering of others have we become?

It's not just Hollywood and movie marketers either. During the Presidents Cup golf event at Royal Melbourne in November, my ailing friend and I sat in the stands behind the 18th green. As we waited for the next foursome to come into view, a small group of spectators took up seats behind us. Someone raised the appearance of a prominent personality.

''Have you seen the pictures?'' one man asked of the others. ''He looks like he's got cancer. He looks like he'll be dead in a few weeks.'' Then they erupted in laughter. My mate, ravaged by illness and looking like it, ignored the comments; I decided not to make an unpleasant situation any more stressful for him, so let it pass. Besides, I'm pretty sure if any of these gentlemen knew my friend was in the final stages of a terminal illness they wouldn't have made those comments. But surely it's time we acknowledged that cancer is never funny. Ever. And that with figures showing one in three adults will be diagnosed with the disease, there's a fair chance that if you're going to say stupid things in public you're probably going to offend someone touched by cancer.

A palliative care nurse told me it is common for patients or their loved ones to be discomfited by the insensitive remarks of others which, in the great majority of cases, are clumsy and unintended, not deliberate. She believes it is partly a product of our inability to discuss serious illness and death in an open and informed way. If we did, we'd realise cancer is no laughing matter, especially with the rate of diagnosis increasing.

Ultimately, she said, we should treat jokes about cancer as we do racist or sexist humour and realise the painful impact they can have on the people around us.

Each of us has, or at least should have, no-go areas in our daily discourse. One of the ABC's most successful radio hosts, Douglas Aiton, once set out for me his list of the medium's dos and don'ts. It ended with one in bold capital letters that said simply: ''And remember, Hitler is never, ever funny.''

Of course he isn't. But that doesn't stop ignorant or insensitive people from clumsily weighing in on the subject from time to time. But I think society generally has accepted that there's no humour in Hitler and the Holocaust. The same can be said about rape and sexual assault. But I'm not sure that's always been the case.

In fact, on cable television you can still see endless re-runs of episodes of The Benny Hill Show that thought nothing of seeking cheap laughs from sexual assault. Or racism. Or sexism, for that matter.

Probably the most egregious example of cancer insensitivity, was The Chaser's appallingly misjudged skit three years ago that parodied terminally ill kids and the Make-A-Wish foundation. It ended with, ''Why go to any trouble when they're only going to die anyway?''

An avalanche of complaints followed, leading to a two-week ban by ABC management and an apology from The Chaser team that acknowledged ''nothing could have justified the pain and anger that it's caused to people who have already suffered so much already''. Though it was excruciating at the time, I suspect The Chaser did us all a favour in accelerating societal recognition that serious illness, whether it's afflicting kids or adults, is not to be trifled with. There's no way such a skit would be contemplated now, much less aired.

Of course, none of this is to suggest that laughter is anything other than terrific medicine. But it should be the patient that chooses whether their illness is a laughing matter, not some insensitive buffoon or a comic or scriptwriter looking for cheap laughs. We should remember that one person's joke is often someone else's anguish.

Bruce Guthrie is a former editor of The Age, The Sunday Age and Herald Sun.

-National TimesAU

Follow the @National TimesAU on Twitter

Print
Increase Text Size
Decrease Text Size
Page:
1

comments


Date: Newest first | Oldest first
BRUCE, I WANT TO SAY GOOD ON U FOR SPEAKING OUT & I WANT TO GIVE U A BIG HUG FOR THAT & IT NOT FUNNY AT FOR SOMEONE MAKE COMMENTS IS A SAD THING THEY NEED TO WAKE UP & THINK BEFORE MAKEING A COMMENTS
Posted by Mrs C, 13/02/2012 8:53:29 AM
geez...get over yourself.

as much as we dont like it, life goes on without us.

why should we spend every living moment watching way we say in case it upsets someone in earshot.

i am a breast (yes i am a male) cancer and prostate cancer survivor.

i hear 'cancer' jokes all the time esp about men having breast cancer.

i am getting on with living (for how long i dont know) not worrying about what other people say.

Posted by nick, 13/02/2012 8:54:35 AM
NICK LET ME TELL U SOMETHING MY MUM DINOSE LUNG CANCER IT'S HIT ALL OF MY FAMLIES & STILL FOR ME I'M STILL SAD ,ANGREY AT TIME I THINK OF HAPPY TIMES WE HAD TOGETHER
Posted by Mrs C, 13/02/2012 9:12:20 AM
"Of course, none of this is to suggest that laughter is anything other than terrific medicine."

Well, can you maybe assist us with what we ARE allowed to joke about, because all we seemed to get was a list of what we can't joke about.

I'm glad you don't know anybody who choked on airline food - poor Jerry Seinfeld would have nothing to talk about.

Posted by LJB, 13/02/2012 10:35:02 AM
Have to agree with LJB there! The guiding rule I think is if there's not any underlying malice or sadism there. Simple.
Posted by INVINCIBLE, 13/02/2012 10:59:15 AM
As a former cancer sufferer and the mother of someone with cancer I think this article is way off track. For goodness sake, get a reality check. They were GLAD it wasn't cancer...so would I be...and the comment actually highlighted how people fear cancer and worry when they think someone has it. They were relieved for God's sake, celebrating it wasn't cancer...just like anyone who gets a negative for a cancer test wants to celebrate. That's not belittling its seriousness, it's recognising it..
Posted by Rhona, 13/02/2012 11:02:24 AM
Invoke Hitler to make a point about humour? Dear or dear, that's what I call inappropriate. I have personal and family history with cancer; we found a certain gallows humour was helpful, rather than po-faced cliches, or people pretending nothing was amiss.. But that was us, and we're all different. You do know Bruce, we all die in the end? Laughing in the face of it is how many of us cope and your excessive sanctity about mordant humour may be more about your own fears than any imputed hurt feelings of your friend and others.
Posted by Harrythecat, 13/02/2012 12:04:10 PM
I was diagnosed with cancer 4 months ago and after surgery, God willing, I'm free of it.

I have no doubt that you were feeling discomfort for your friend. You wouldn't be much of a friend if you didn't! And if I had a choice between a sensitive, caring friend like you or one of those sitting behind you at the golf, I'll take you everytime!


Posted by Sereena, 13/02/2012 12:42:45 PM
I would like to know Bruce, did you ask your friend how they felt about it or did you presume that you knew how they were feeling?? They might have been having a laugh themselves!

I have just finished 12 months of cancer treatment and have realised that I looked at everthing differently from the way my friends did and that they were almost like, protective of me and but sometimes had no idea of what I was feeling about situations.

I agree with Rhona, it is celebrating that it was not cancer!

I feel that it is more belitttling divorce than cancer!

Posted by Overit, 14/02/2012 9:35:36 AM
They say that `laughter is the best medicine'. On the other hand, insensitive comments, even if well meant, can cause further pain to those afflicted with a terminal illness, and to their close family, relatives and friends. If in doubt, `a closed mouth catches no flies'!
Posted by Jacqueline, 15/02/2012 3:50:03 PM
National Comment
Here is the place for you to vent on any national or world news and lifestyle stories on the YourGuide websites. If there is anything you see or hear that you like or don't like, tell us. Don't keep it to yourself!
'Each of us has, at least should have, no-go areas in our daily discourse'.
'Each of us has, at least should have, no-go areas in our daily discourse'.

Most popular articles




Hawkesbury Gazette







Weather brought to you by:

Weatherzone

Front Page

Current Issue
Privacy Policy | Conditions of Use | Advertising Terms | Copyright © 2012. Fairfax Media.
 SEND...
 SAVE...
 SHARE...